Calculus · Eqora guide

Implicit differentiation homework: keep dy/dx

Keep dy/dx in implicit differentiation. Review product and chain rules with Eqora, check a tangent and solve a changed exercise independently.

Man in a rust overshirt holding a cream cord above a notebook at a gray drafting table in a teal loft

Your derivative looks tidy, yet the tangent slope disagrees with your earlier calculation. The likely difficulty is small: a term involving y was differentiated as though y were constant, or the product xy lost one of its two contributions. Implicit differentiation homework becomes easier to inspect when every occurrence of y is treated consistently as part of a local function y(x).

We will work through an original curve, use Eqora to review one uncertain step and then solve a changed exercise independently. The cord and notebook photographs suggest connected quantities and careful working; they are not graphs, measurements or evidence for any formula. All mathematical information comes from the equations in the text.

Read your implicit differentiation homework first

Take x² + xy + y² = 7 and find the tangent at (1, 2). There are two tasks: obtain an expression for dy/dx, then evaluate it at a point on the curve. First check membership: 1² + 1×2 + 2² = 1 + 2 + 4 = 7. The given point qualifies. A derivative formula evaluated at an unrelated point would not answer this tangent question.

The equation describes a relationship between x and y. It need not describe a single global function of x. For our calculation we follow a differentiable local branch through the specified point. The derivative is its local rate of change, not the result of solving the original equation for one numerical value of y.

Keep the original relation, requested derivative and coordinates together on the page. Check whether the question asks for dy/dx or dx/dy: these are different operations. Our independent variable is x throughout. The constant seven stays fixed, and its derivative with respect to x is zero.

Why differentiating y produces another factor

Writing y(x) makes the dependence visible. Differentiating y² means differentiating [y(x)]². The outer square contributes 2y, and the inner function contributes y′, giving 2yy′. Here y′ is simply shorter notation for dy/dx. It is not the number one, a second copy of y or an extra variable chosen after differentiation.

By contrast, d(x²)/dx = 2x because dx/dx = 1. Both operations follow the chain rule; the inner derivative happens to be one for x itself. A constant coefficient remains a multiplier: d(3y²)/dx = 6yy′. Treating y as constant would instead compute a different kind of derivative, which is not what this exercise requests.

If the language of inner and outer functions is unfamiliar, revisit the explanation of calculus concepts and changing quantities. For this task, write one derivative for each original term before combining anything. That extra line gives you a place to detect a missing factor without guessing from the final answer.

Two loosely curved cream cords crossing on a gray table beside a wooden pencil

The product xy needs two contributions

The middle term xy is a product of two quantities that depend on x. Its derivative is (dx/dx)y + x(dy/dx), or y + xy′. Differentiating the two factors and multiplying their derivatives would give y′, which is not the product rule. Keeping only xy′ would miss the contribution from the changing first factor.

For the whole curve, termwise differentiation gives 2x + y + xy′ + 2yy′ = 0. Compare this line directly with x² + xy + y² = 7. The square in x gives one contribution, the product gives two, the square in y supplies a chain-rule factor, and the constant gives zero.

This is the same two-term structure explained in the worked product-rule guide, now with y representing a function rather than a fixed symbol. Mark the two contributions from xy separately in your notebook. A correct final slope is more useful when you can identify the rule that produced each term along the way.

Collect y prime before dividing

Group the terms containing y′: xy′ + 2yy′ = −2x − y. Factoring the left side gives (x + 2y)y′ = −(2x + y). Only now divide by x + 2y to obtain y′ = −(2x + y)/(x + 2y), provided x + 2y is nonzero at the point under consideration.

The minus sign applies to the entire numerator. Writing −2x + y above the denominator would change the result. Parentheses make the intended grouping explicit, especially if you later enter the expression on a phone. The numerator and denominator are sums; matching symbols cannot simply be cancelled across their addition signs.

At (1, 2), the denominator is five, so the division is valid and the slope is −4/5. Check the unsolved derivative relation: 2 + 2 + 1×(−4/5) + 4×(−4/5) = 4 − 4 = 0. This verifies the algebraic substitution into the differentiated equation, alongside the separate original-point check.

Open blank notebook with a pencil and folded teal paper on a gray table

Turn the slope into the requested tangent

Use point-slope form with the verified point and slope: y − 2 = (−4/5)(x − 1). This line passes through (1, 2) and has slope −4/5. Expanded form is also acceptable when requested, but point-slope form preserves the connection between the numerical slope and the given coordinates.

A tangent is a local linear approximation, not the original curve. Nearby points on the tangent generally do not satisfy x² + xy + y² = 7 exactly. For example, moving x by a small amount predicts a corresponding change in y using the slope; it does not turn that approximation into an exact solution of the curve equation.

Do not substitute (1, 2) into the original equation before differentiating and then differentiate the resulting 7 = 7. That would remove the variable dependence you need to study. Check membership first, keep x and y symbolic during differentiation, and insert the coordinates only after you have a valid expression or relation for the slope.

Capture the complete problem with Eqora

If you are unsure about the product step, open Eqora and capture the clearly written problem using the available photo or input flow. Include the original equation, the requested dy/dx and the point. Keep exponents, parentheses and the prime mark readable, with even light and the worksheet flat. A cropped-out coordinate can change what the explanation needs to address.

Compare the recognized problem with your own page before reviewing any solution. Check that xy remains a product, y² remains a square and the constant is seven. A transcription error must be corrected before judging the subsequent working. The capture photograph here illustrates preparation only; it does not show an actual app screen or a tested recognition result.

Remove names and unrelated personal details from the capture. Use Eqora only where your course permits assistance, and keep your initial attempt. The purpose is to inspect the uncertain reasoning, rather than obtain a polished answer that you cannot reproduce. The same basic learning workflow is relevant on the available iOS and Android versions.

Man holding the back of a black smartphone above a cream worksheet on a drafting table

Ask about the first uncertain equality

Review the explanation against your termwise derivative line. If it jumps from xy to y + xy′ without explaining why, ask: “In x² + xy + y² = 7, why does differentiating xy with respect to x give y + xy′? Show both product-rule contributions.” This names the precise obstacle instead of requesting the whole solution again.

A second useful question is: “Why does differentiating y² give 2yy′, while differentiating x² gives 2x?” Compare the answer with the chain-rule reasoning above. Do not accept a response merely because it contains the expected final slope. Confirm that its assumptions, notation and intermediate equalities match the actual problem you entered.

Return to your notebook and write the disputed line without looking at the screen. Then explain aloud what y′ represents. If you still omit a contribution, revisit that single rule before continuing. Eqora can support this exchange, but an explanation can still contain mistakes; your explicit checks remain part of the work.

Solve a changed example independently

Close the explanation and try x² + 2xy + 3y² = 6 at (1, 1). First verify 1 + 2 + 3 = 6. Differentiate the complete equation: 2x + 2y + 2xy′ + 6yy′ = 0. The coefficient two multiplies both product-rule contributions from xy, while the coefficient three changes the derivative of y² to 6yy′.

Collecting terms gives (2x + 6y)y′ = −2x − 2y. Hence y′ = −(x + y)/(x + 3y) wherever the denominator is nonzero. At (1, 1), this is −2/4 = −1/2, and the tangent is y − 1 = (−1/2)(x − 1). Check the derivative relation numerically: 2 + 2 − 1 − 3 = 0.

Compare the process, not just the two final fractions. The coefficients and point changed, but the decisions remained stable: identify the independent variable, apply chain and product rules, collect the unknown derivative, check division and evaluate. Reproducing that sequence without assistance is stronger evidence of learning than recognising a familiar answer on a screen.

Woman in a charcoal cardigan writing independently in a notebook beside a frosted window

Respect the denominator and the local branch

A zero denominator in the slope formula is a signal to investigate, not permission to write a finite answer. For our first curve, x + 2y = 0 implies y = −x/2. Substitution into the original equation gives 3x²/4 = 7. At those two curve points, 2x + y is nonzero, so a finite dy/dx cannot satisfy the differentiated relation.

The curve has vertical tangents there. This conclusion uses both the curve equation and the derivative relation; a denominator of zero alone is not a universal proof of a vertical tangent for every implicit curve. In other problems both relevant coefficients can vanish, requiring more analysis. Do not erase that distinction by cancelling a factor without checking its value.

For routine homework, state where your division is valid and inspect any excluded points separately if requested. Our assigned point has denominator five, so the ordinary local tangent calculation is legitimate. There is no need to invent a global branch formula merely to evaluate that one verified slope.

Keep a record you can use on the next question

Record the first incorrect equality, the relevant rule and one corrected line in your error log. “Forgot y′ in d(y²)/dx” is more actionable than “bad at derivatives.” On the next exercise, leave enough space to differentiate each original term separately, and check the product contributions before gathering the terms containing the unknown derivative.

Eqora publishes this guide and is presented as its own learning aid, not as an independently ranked recommendation. No recognition accuracy, grade improvement or guaranteed correctness is claimed. The value of the review depends on the problem you provide and the checking you perform. Follow assessment rules and complete any work that must be unaided yourself.

Finish by checking the requested notation, the original point, the derivative relation, the nonzero divisor and the tangent through the stated coordinates. If any of those checks fails, locate the first mismatch before asking for another full answer. That habit transfers to a new curve, even when the symbols no longer look like this example.

Your next problem, with a clearer path

Ready to understand the math?

Scan a problem, ask follow-up questions, and turn one difficult step into a method you can use again.

Good to know

Questions about this guide